Blog · Lean

FMEA: what it is and how it is carried out

FMEA is a way of finding out in advance what can go wrong in a product or process and deciding what to deal with first. The name stands for Failure Mode and Effects Analysis.

The point of the method is the order of actions. Usually you find out about a defect when it has already happened: a complaint comes in, the line stops. FMEA reverses the order: the team sits down before launch and goes through possible failures on paper, while fixing them is still cheap.

Types of FMEA

Two types are used most often:

  • Design FMEA — looks for weak points in the product itself: what can break, wear out or fail under load.
  • Process FMEA — looks for where a defect can occur during manufacture or service delivery: wrong tightening torque, mixed-up components, a skipped operation.

The method originated in the military and aerospace industries and was then taken up by the automotive industry, but it works wherever there is a repetitive process and the cost of a mistake is significant: in food production, healthcare, logistics.

How the analysis is carried out

  1. Assemble a team. A process engineer, a designer, a quality inspector, the area supervisor, sometimes a representative of the service department. One person does not see the whole process.
  2. Describe the object. The process is broken down into operations, the product into components and functions.
  3. List possible failures. For each operation or function, answer the question: what can go wrong?
  4. Determine the effects and causes. What the failure means for the customer and the next operation, and what can cause it.
  5. Record how the failure is currently prevented and detected. Which checks and safeguards are already in place.
  6. Rate it on three scales, usually from 1 to 10.
  7. Plan actions for the most dangerous failures, and assign responsible persons and deadlines.
  8. Re-rate after the actions are completed and make sure the risk has gone down.

Three ratings and the risk priority number

Each failure is rated on three parameters:

  • Severity (S) — how serious the consequences are. 1 — the customer will not notice, 10 — a threat to safety.
  • Occurrence (O) — how often the cause leads to failure. 1 — practically never, 10 — almost always.
  • Detection (D) — how likely it is that the failure will be missed. 1 — current controls will certainly catch it, 10 — there is no way to detect it.

In the classic version the ratings are multiplied to give the risk priority number: RPN = S × O × D. It ranges from 1 to 1,000. The higher the number, the sooner the failure needs to be dealt with.

The product has a weakness: a rare failure with serious consequences can get the same number as a harmless but frequent one. So failures with high severity are analysed in any case, even with a low RPN. Newer automotive guidelines replace the RPN with an action priority, which is read from a table instead of being calculated by multiplication.

An example FMEA table

A hypothetical example for a food packaging process. The ratings are for illustration and are not taken from a real company.

Operation Possible failure Effect Cause S O D RPN
Bag sealing Leaking seam Product spoils before its expiry date Sealing temperature dropped 8 4 5 160
Date printing Date is illegible Batch returned by the retail chain Printer ribbon ran out 6 3 2 36
Packing into boxes Wrong quantity in the box Short-delivery complaint Manual counting error 4 5 6 120

The table shows where to start: with sealing. Possible actions are a temperature sensor that stops the line, to reduce occurrence, and an hourly sample check of the seam, to improve detection. After implementation, the ratings are assigned again.

Where FMEA most often breaks down

  • One person does the analysis at a desk. The result is a formal table that lacks what the workers and supervisors know.
  • Ratings are adjusted to get the desired number. The scales must be described in advance and be the same for everyone.
  • The table was filled in and put away in a folder. FMEA is a living document: it is reviewed when the process changes, after complaints and when a new product is launched.
  • Actions were recorded but not carried out. Without responsible persons and deadlines, the table changes nothing.

How FMEA relates to ISO 9001 and lean manufacturing

ISO 9001 requires an organization to determine risks and plan actions to address them, but does not name a specific method. FMEA is one of the most common ways to meet this requirement for production processes.

In lean manufacturing, FMEA is used together with other tools: it shows where error proofing is needed and where a work standard is enough.